- Ca. 1808 - 1812
- Buenos Aries National Museum of Fine Arts, Buenos Aires, Argentina
- 72 x 99 cm
- Técnica y soporte
- Oil on canvas
- Reconocimiento de la autoría de Goya
- Undisputed work
- National Museum of Fine Arts, Argentina
- Ficha: realización/revisión
- 16 May 2010 / 14 Mar 2023
X.28 (lower left-hand corner).
The first information on these works was published by the Count de la Viñaza in 1887, who recorded them in the Madrid collection of Eustaquio López, which was sold in 1866. According to Juan Corradini (1965), in 1886 Miguel Cané, the Argentine ambassador to Spain, on the advice of the Duke of Alba, bought six paintings by Goya, including The Fire and War Scene, as well as Procession of Discipliners, commissioned by Gabriel Larsen del Castaño; Popular Feast, bought by Parmenio T. Piñero, and two paintings acquired by the Jockey Club of Buenos Aires.
In 1907, Popular Feast entered the Museum through the Piñero bequest. The remaining three were in the possession of the Ugarte family, who auctioned them in 1954, at which time doubts again arose as to their authorship. They were acquired by Horacio Acevedo with the intention of donating them to the MNBA, where they entered in 1958 by donation of his brothers Carlos Alberto, Arturo and Eduardo Acevedo.
Thanks to the inscription X.28 that appears on this canvas, it has been possible to identify this work and to attribute it to the artist, together with three others: Bandit Scene, Festivities underneath a Bridge and The Hurricane. These four paintings correspond to those which appear in the inventory drawn up in 1812, following the death of Josefa Bayeu, and which were labelled with the number 28: "Four paintings of other subjects, with the no. 28, [valued] at sixty reales".
In the foreground, a group of people are fleeing in terror from a flaming building. A woman who has fainted or perhaps suffocated is being carried on a stretcher by a group of men.
In thematic and formal terms, this work very closely resembles The Fire, also known as Fire at Night, which Goya painted between 1793 and 1794. In both paintings we see people running away, crashing into one another in their confusion. In the centre of both compositions, the artist has created a brightly painted area representing the fire itself and occupying much of the canvas. Both works also feature an unconscious person who is being transported by others and which we can relate to the body sprawled out over the rocks in A Shipwreck. However, in Fire in a Hospital, Goya shows an increasing tendency to abstraction; the brushstrokes are looser and the setting in which the fire takes place is even less defined here than in the painting that the Aragonese artist made during his stay in Cádiz. The human figures appear to be of lesser importance and are scattered over the surface of the canvas. This device could have been an allusion to the lack of cohesion or solidarity between the victims of the unhappy event.
The painting in the Museum of Fine Arts in Buenos Aires must be considered in the light of Goya's interest in themes of disasters. It is likely that part of this interest came as a result of the artist having come into contact with the treatise by Edmund Burke (Dublin, 1729-Beaconsfield, 1797) on the sublime, published in 1757 (A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful). Burke stated that, the closer a representation of a disaster is to reality, the more perfect its power. It is that very realism, which the painter does not seek to avoid, which contains the work's ability to arouse in the viewer a mixture of terror and morbid curiosity.
It is possible that Goya had heard about the fire which destroyed the theatre at the Hospital of Nuestra Señora de Gracia in Zaragoza in 1778. This place, which staged all sorts of different shows, was founded in the 16th century. The takings from the performances put on at the theatre were used to pay for the upkeep of the hospital.
L'œuvre peint de Goya. 4 volsParís1928-1950p. 298, cat. 277
Don Francisco de Goya y LucientesBuenos AiresPoseidón1942p. 69
La pintura española moderna y contemporáneaMadrid1964fig. 25
Paintings by Goya in the Buenos Aires MuseumThe Burlington MagazineCVIILondon1965pp. 11-16
Vie et ouvre de Francisco de GoyaParísOffice du livre1970p. 265, cat. 947
vol. I, pp. 356 y 357, cat. 614
L’opera pittorica completa di GoyaMilanRizzoli1974p. 125, cat. 527
“Incendio en un hospital en el siglo XVIII. Análisis del acontecimiento descrito por Francisco de Goya y Lucientes”Índex de enfermería: información bibliográfica, investigación y humanidades18, 42009pp. 276-280